‘Love, which allows no one who is loved to escape,
Seized me so strongly with my pleasure in him,
That, as you see, it does not leave me now.’
Dante, Divine Comedy: Inferno V, 103–105
Star-crossed lovers? Certainly not. They could hardly compare to poor Paolo and Francesca, those adulterous amoureux punished by Dante for their passion. Literature as inspiration has much to answer for. All that violent intrigue and infidelity in ancient myth, or culpability in those conventions that arose in courtly love. Loyal devotion, wanton rebellion, cautionary tales penned to inspire and compel; literature has it all. Those legends of passion prized by artists, worked into images or sculptures, are incarnations to beguile us still.
Before she met André, Chloe liked to imagine herself wise to the pitfalls of ill-fated romance. This was the image held firmly in her mind, that mute chant when scrutinizing her reflection before the mirror. Passionate encounters could, she believed, be cultivated and controlled to endure. Careful observation of others had shown it was all in the phrasing and pose. How playfully they flirted, how concentrated they looked sitting, silently brooding, bodies taut with yearning, barely touching but held close. How enviable they were - utterly distracted, their minds consumed as if intoxicated. Lovers were like twins, always together on the periphery of any group; always with some secret entirely their own. Neither, it appeared, would ever tire of that intensity in their bond.
It was that which drew so many to the museum. That display of affection unquestionable in its magnetism, solid and consistent in its sculpted marble form. Visitors did not flock in their droves to see the edifying tale of the historical Burghers, humility and self-sacrifice for the greater good moulded and cast in weary, tormented expressions and emaciated bodies. No, it was not that sculpture they came to admire. Not that work which marshalled them all into line where they stood, wrestling with impatience, defensively holding their place in the queue snaking down the rue de Varenne.
That day Chloe had had to persuade André, had taken him by the arm, pulled him close, attempting to soothe his sulking frown and resentful murmuring. He knew the work well, and wasn’t in the mood to see it again. She leaned back, searching in his face - but it was Rodin that brought them together, surely he hadn’t forgotten? One afternoon, only the year before last, when Chloe had been admiring two Rodin drawings in a gallery window display. She saw him in the reflection first, a man who had stopped suddenly, seemingly caught by some fleeting impression impossible to ignore, and who stood next to her gazing down at the images, close enough for her to feel his presence. What an exquisite moment that had been - a fortuitous meeting weighted with promise, the silent agreement between their two figures aligned in contemplation. Wasn’t this, she had thought, the encounter she had so long been waiting for?
“You don’t do this when you live here,” he muttered now, his body stiffened with bruised pride. “Visit on a day like this with all these other people.” She held his hand a little tighter, nudging his back towards the wall, reminding him of the game they had decided to play. She had decided they’d play. People-spotting, jostling against the tourists, united in their knowing gazes and wry smiles.
This was another kind of experience: “We are flâneurs, remember?” And she leaned closer, planting a kiss on his cheek. She fluttered her eyelashes, feigning a coquettish smile. She knew she was working hard.
Working. Was that what it had become? She had to cajole him, pull his glance away, that sneering stare he held at others. They might not notice, but she could not ignore the scornful looks he cast towards the tourists with their bum-bags and walking shoes. In the museum Chloe hoped André would be her captive audience, appreciative of all she had learned from her research. Their outing would be an occasion to rekindle what had been so fervent at the start. Pride made her persist in prompting, vainly longing for him to be for once, again, attentive to her.
She soon realised it would be no easy task. He was too irritated by all the visitors, too absorbed in his disdain at children staring, mouths agape. It could not be that he felt discomfort sharing the floor with couples who circled the figures with admiring envy. It was not embarrassment that made him mute. André never would admit to finding something alarming, of that Chloe was sure. It was some other distraction that sent his glance darting about as though he were searching amongst the people in the room. Why had she not noticed this before?
She leant closer to give her commentary. “Paolo and Francesca. I hadn’t realised they were historical contemporaries of Dante. Italian nobility, united through marriage as brother and sister-in-law, who were unfortunate enough to fall so passionately, so fatally, in love.” There was a brief nod from André, the knowing dismissal of one apparently familiar with the tale. But she continued, walking behind, still whispering, her voice creeping over his shoulder.
“Dante spins their story into the stuff of legend. Their first illicit kiss is elicited while reading together the tale of Lancelot and Guinevere. Two pairs of ill-fated lovers woven into Dante’s own narrative.” Chloe remembered how disappointed she had been to read that Dante, too censorious in his moralising, allows Paolo and Francesca but a brief moment before they are brutally slain by Giovanni, brother and husband. Then, as if this were not enough, they are cruelly cast into swirling tumults, their punishment to be lost for infinity in the tempest of Hell. She could not linger at this ending. She had searched frantically, her fingers tapping vigorously on her keyboard, her shoulders hunched, face peering at the screen, leaning back in her chair only once she had enough to content herself with an alternate view of their tale. The kiss.
“That is the inspiration for so many other artists too: an embrace so precious they are held at a distance from the rest of the world. But look at how Rodin gives us so much more.”
Chloe paused, watching André as he walked on ahead of her, ambling slowly yet seeming equally impatient to lead the way. She caught a glance he gave the tourists snapping their selfies, snapshots sent as love-tokens: here, they say, I am thinking of you. She sensed her own stab of envy, a sharp prick even in that trite association, a simple message cast out to one’s lover on the other side of the world, while there was she, standing at his side, struggling against her lover’s scorn. She should have guessed then at his irritation, should have retreated silently, but she did not. She stepped towards him and he twisted away, staring upwards, lifting his chin with that assumed confidence sharply indifferent to her words; she could not but feel it keenly. He must have known he was taunting her, walking round the figures, arms poised with palms together behind his back, that contemplative posture for pacing; his back turned on her every word.
There hadn’t been that need for effort or persuasion when it all began. They had slipped so easily into one another’s arms. It never did cross her mind to consider whether one was leading the other. Not in those early days when adulation was still a novelty, the fascination to explore reciprocal, their bodies constantly seeking out each other’s as though every gesture were a silently complicit exchange. Kisses full of ardour. He did seduction well, especially at first. She had felt herself falling.
Looking back on those early days, for it was only in hindsight that she could see, she had known what it meant to feel entranced. A kiss on the back of the neck, in a café, on only their second date. Or had it been the first? He had moved quickly. She had been caught, surprise a bare flicker in her mind, quashed by a quite different sensation. Only later, much later, with that distance once the infatuation had faded, would she question. His presumptuousness. Her languid pleasure. She had been such easy prey.
How had it started to change? Just as imperceptibly as it had begun. Familiarity led to acceptance for beneath that lay the memory of what had united them at the start. Those small incremental shifts, of dishes from a menu no longer proffered for tasting, comments sparking a venting of ire no longer concealed. Anecdotes of former girlfriends increasing, their character flaws imprinted on her mind, and Chloe made note, registering his warnings that she might never wish to become comparable.
She did not object when their kisses became briefer, slighter, until they were no longer part of greetings or goodbyes; as if it was no longer deemed necessary, or too close to a domestic convention he wished to shun. She had tried not to notice the changes, the pauses lengthening into silence, an awkward stillness now of people no longer wishing to share. The tardy arrivals and messages perfunctory, thinned of the flourish that had once made her smile. Time could not be held accountable. There had not been long years of marriage nor co-habiting to dull their desire. That kind of complacency she could understand.
At first, that defiant spirit in him had a certain allure. His assured air of utmost self-belief, such a promising mark of confidence, a companionable counterpoint to some element lacking in herself. Now, when she reflected, Chloe could not imagine André listening or deferring to anyone; humility contrary to his character, he would be sure to avoid any circumstance of knowledge affronting him. In conversation, she had hung on his every word, enjoyed the tales of his adventures, her own never seeming quite enough to reveal. How easily she had become his captive audience, her questions posed to ease his flow.
She blamed it on the kiss. Those initial embraces so strong and engrossing. Nights when, walking hand in hand, they had stopped in darkened streets oblivious to any passer-by. Had he listened to her then? She thought back. They had found common interests, some at least they could share. But then he had taken her hand, pulled her towards him, pressed his lips to her mouth.
When had the kisses ceased? The last, other than playful pecks she had given him, she could not recall. Now there was only the arm outstretched at night to flip her body over, his hand firmly grasping her shoulder, rough thrusting, deeper and faster, his attention entirely his own. He barely touched the back of her neck where once he had been so attentive and tender. She had grown used to his face falling heavily, his breath hot against her skin, a deep sigh pulling in all the air he needs, she feeling little more than the sheets below and his weight upon her. She no longer attempted any sound.
But there, that day in the gallery, she persisted, ignoring the discomfort dawning, circling after him in a scurry; she would not relent, would not submit.
“Rodin is not so damning of the human spirit searching for desire. His is not a fable, like Dante’s, of perilous pursuit, a mere kiss enough to seal their fate.” She stopped, a pause that halted André too. “Rodin captures his characters in their pleasure, Francesca as much as Paolo.” Perhaps, Chloe thought, Francesca even a little more. She watched André’s eyes dart across the sculpture. He stood still as if allowing her one moment of his attention. Focus on the physical, she remembered, have him look at the way those bodies, so corporeal, speak of desire.
“See how intently the woman pulls herself up towards her lover’s embrace.” Chloe paused, wanting to run her hand along Francesca’s creamy arm, to the hand reaching, wrapped firm around Paolo’s neck; how inviting the turn of her body made that kiss appear. A woman utterly absorbed, immersing onlookers; in taking the lead Francesca is intent on having her fill of desire.
“His pose—” She stopped again, André was still there, listening. “His pose seems almost more tentative, that hand resting only lightly on her thigh. His is a muscular body of masculine force, but see her back, her arms and thighs, her body animated, physical and strong. She is no ephemeral spirit coyly restrained in flawless form.” André had begun to circle the sculpture again. She had not noticed the crowds disappear. It was just the two of them there in the gallery. She continued, her voice echoing round the room.
“Rodin prided himself on provocation. We admire the bodies, their fleshy naturalism as much as their pose. There’s no high polish or effete gesture to cast them as gods. This is the mastery of Rodin: human form and feeling.” André was looking away, distracted again, now by the row of portrait busts lining the far wall, softly rendered visages of dreamy women emerging from chiselled blocks of stone. Chloe knew she could not tell him any more about The Kiss. It would not interest him to know that critics refer to this as a defining work of the period; a rare example of the female figure imbued with agency. That, she realised, was something André would never wish to understand.
In the next gallery, where the lighting was lowered and thin blinds were pulled down to keep out the sun, few tourists lingered, as if unsure what to make of the fluid forms of female nudes floating on the page. Rodin’s drawings. Would André remember? There were preparatory sketches for those larger sculpted works, but also his practice and exploration from his studio, the figures spare and sinuous, bodies sketched in watercolour barely contained by pencil lines drawn on the page. Their poses were at once graceless and affronting, their legs spread, sex revealed, crouching, rolling to one side readying the body to stand upright. They might be acrobats or dancers, their bodies contorted, defying the meek gestures of nymphs and goddesses of the idealised classical style. There Chloe saw female forms elusive and vital; women more nimble and unrestrained than any male counterpart. She walked to stand behind André, reaching out her hand, placing it firmly on his shoulder. His muscles tensed and she saw his face bristling. She clenched her fingers tighter. He could not ignore her now. She would not have him peer through those lazy eyes glazed with indifference. She would have him listen to her words.
“Look around you,” she whispered, her voice sharp in his ear. “No, look more closely.” She was insistent. His expression flickered, alert to slight alarm. There she had him, but it was no longer desire. Her pleasure she would have later for one final night. She would wrestle him beneath her, clamp his body between her thighs, she as solid as the marble Francesca just to show him something of her will. She no longer cared how he might retell their story, how he tired of her needy inclinations. He would have no chance for that vain sneer, she would thrust her hands down over his face, smother his eyes, his mouth – the satisfaction of that instant would be hers alone. Her fingers dug deeper into his shoulder; she did not withdraw her hand as she might have done before if she sensed he would pull away. He would cast her as the crazed character and at this Chloe smiled; there would be no wan fading away in her story.
But at that moment, standing alone in the gallery after André had wandered into the next room, Chloe turned back to the drawings. She no longer wished for someone to appear beside her, his reflection looming in the glass of the display case. Passion, she would find again. Until then she would not be ill-fated as those legendary characters condemned to be buffeted and blown by the tumultuous winds of Hell. She wanted nothing to disrupt her pleasure in those images, a single figure on each page, bodies of an agile and sinuous beauty; bodies that rose up from their poses, danced, whirled and leapt with a spirit and energy entirely their own.
Bio:
Mabel Leigh is an art historian and teacher. She has lived in Paris and London, and is now based in the south of England. She writes short stories in her spare time.